What is the Best Gutter Guard System?

A woman seeks direction, in this case - which is the best gutter cover system in Kansas City?

The Must-Read Guide for Identifying the Best Gutter Guard System in KC

You know keeping your gutters clean is important for protecting the health, safety, and longevity of your home. But…let’s face it…you’ve got better things to do than clean your gutters every weekend until winter. So, this year you’re going to maximize your time and have gutter guards installed. Brilliant idea! But now the question is, ‘Which gutter cover is best?’

3 Reasons Why Advantage Gutter Guard® is the Best Gutter Protection System

1. Design

    1. Industry leading technology
    2. Durable construction with no plastic parts
    3. Designed in Kansas City for Kansas City 

2. Backed By A Reputable Company

    1. Installed by professionals
    2. Product and company Highly rated on all platforms
    3. 20 Years in Business

3. Permanent Solution With Lifetime Guarantee That Gutters Will Never Clog


Get a free estimate now or read on to find out why these 3 factors are so important for a gutter cover system, and why Advantage Gutter Guard® is unique in these aspects.

Gutter Cover Clarity – An Expert’s Guide

1. Screen Gutter Guards

Traditional Gutter Screens

Good News:

This design system has been around the longest. Most of us are familiar with the metal net that weaves over the top of the gutters. Familiarity is nice.

Bad News:

However, you’re also likely familiar with seedlings growing up through the metal screen and if left alone – becoming luxurious baby trees.

These gutter guards work by keeping large maple leaves out of the gutter,  but dirt, seeds, and smaller leaves have no trouble getting in. So, while it might save you an intermittent clean, you still will need to clean your entire gutter system – and your gutter screens a couple of times a year. It’s pretty clear, this design is not the best gutter cover system available.

From inside the gutter you can see the dirt and debris collected, and a new plant is growing up through the gutter screen

Leaf Filters

Good News:

A new model of screen has been developed to prevent this seedling debacle. It is a micro-mesh system with perforations so small it is essentially a mesh filter. These filters not only keep leaves out – they also keep seeds and other debris out. It appears to be a very pragmatic design. 

Bad News:

Unfortunately, micro-mesh gutter guards still have issues: The fine filter clogs with tree sap and dirt over time. It also traps debris on top of the filter. Once clogged, the water can’t pour in through the mesh and is forced to run over the gutters and down to the foundation of your home – exactly what you’re trying to avoid. To keep gutter filters in shape, it is essential to give them a good scrub a couple of times a year. Not quite the gutter cleaning task you were looking forward to.

clogged leaf filter/ micromesh screen

2. Foam Gutter Guards

Good News:

Foam gutter guards are what they sound like – large sponge-like material that fills up the top 3/4 of your gutter and prevents any debris to enter your guttering system. No debris! Yay!

Bad News:

They fill up 3/4 of your gutters leaving only 25% water capacity. This will work for most light rains, but after a few months, dirt will continue to filter through the sponge, closing that 25% water capacity to 20%, then 15%, you get the picture. 

The result: eventually there’s simply not enough space in the channel to process the thousands of gallons of water that rushes off your roof and into your gutters. This means the water that should be in your gutters is flowing past the gutters and down your siding, landing in your prized flower beds and weakening your home’s foundation. So basically, back to square one.


sponge leaf filter does not work because it fills the gutter and mud builds up under it.

3. Brush Gutter Guard

Good News:

Brush gutter guards sit inside the gutter, catching leaves, pine needles, and other debris in their stiff bristles. They’re generally budget-friendly, making them an attractive option for those looking to enhance their gutter protection without breaking the bank. Moreover, installation is a breeze. Even if you’re not a seasoned DIY enthusiast, the process of setting up these guards requires minimal experience and skill, allowing most homeowners to quickly and efficiently fit them in place. 

Bad News:

Despite their functionality in trapping smaller debris, you’ll find that larger debris and leaves can often stick to the stiff bristles, preventing them from effectively keeping the gutters clear. Eventually, all this trapped debris accumulates to a point where the gutters cannot allow water to pass through.  At that point, it is time to take out the brushes, clean them and the gutter, and reinstall. So eventually you’ll find yourself on your ladder to remove the brushes. To be fair, the cleaning process is simple and you can use a hose to clean the bristles and the gutter. If you’re looking to stay off the ladder or a more permanent solution, gutter brushes are probably not the answer. Gutter brushes still need regular cleaning and maintenance of your gutters, even with the guards in place. Additionally, their lifespan is somewhat limited and they will have to be replaced every few years.

4. Solid Gutter Guards

Good News:

These are completely solid so no debris large or small can enter – no clogged gutters, guaranteed! Woo-Hoo! 

But wait a minute…if they’re completely solid, how does the water get in? 

A well-designed solid gutter cover uses the water principle of surface tension to drive the flow of the water around the edge of the cover and into the gutter. This might be something you have to see to believe, but it is scientifically based and does actually work, even in heavy rains.

A high-quality solid gutter cover will work for your home in Kansas City and is the best gutter cover system.

Bad News:

Be warned when installing gutter guards some products that are considered solid covers don’t fully cover the gutter – they leave a small gap at the edge of the gutter to allow water in. Such products will have the same struggles as a screen because dirt, seeds, pine needles, and small leaves can enter. Be sure when selecting a solid cover that the entire gutter is covered and surface tension is used to guide the water into the gutter.

In addition, some solid gutter cover systems are designed to replace your existing gutter system, which can be very expensive. The lesson – choose the right solid gutter system!


solid gutter guard/gutter cover design for homes in Kansas City and it's suburbs like Lake Lotawana

What The Neighbors Say

So now you know you’re looking for a solid gutter guard and you’re ready to find a company that provides the best gutter cover system in the area. It’s always a good idea to check the reviews of each company you’re considering. Check not just one source – but multiple – FaceBook, HomeAdvisor, Google, Angie’s List, BBB. 

Companies can release fake reviews and bury less-flattering reviews. It’s important to check multiple sites, read with discernment and dig a little – with a little research – the truth will reveal itself. 

As you read, you will likely find that many people have tried multiple products until finding the right one. Read what they have to say – likely this research will save you much headache – and reaffirm your interest in solid gutter covers.

Chuck and Sue think that Advantage Gutter Guard is the best gutter cover for their home.

Where to Buy Gutter Covers

Really there are two option for purchasing gutter covers.

1. From a Home Improvement Store


Most inexpensive at onset.


1. You get what you pay for; products available at the stores have openings at the top – which means they will have all the problems that gutter screens and leaf filters have.

This isn’t because they want to offer an inferior product, it’s just that for a layperson to install gutter guards, larger areas for water entry are required for proper water flow. 

Completely solid gutter covers that use surface tension must be installed by an expert who understands how to maximize surface tension. 

2. You will have to install it yourself or pay a handyman to install it for you. 

3. Most DIY gutter guards come with limited or no warranties

Home Depot product was not installed by experts, and is not functioning at all. It is clearly not the best gutter cover system in Kansas City

2. From a Gutter Protection Company 


    1. Professional evaluation to make sure your gutters are working optimally before a gutter cover system is installed.
    2. The product will be installed by trained professionals who understand how the gutter cover works.
    3. Professional gutter guards usually come with a warranty, guaranteeing your gutters will never clog. 
    4. Trained experts to call if you’re having an issue after installation.


A more expensive option, but worth the investment if the company is reputable.  

corner installation of 8 inch gutters


Buying Tips

1. Before scheduling an appointment, check multiple review sites and the Better Business Bureau to see if it is a reputable company.

2. When meeting with each company, determine if the estimator is interested in the overall result for your home and not just pushing a product.

You can do this by seeing if the gutter expert is truly that: Did they check the condition and slope of your gutters? Or how the downspouts interact with the ground slope of your home? etc. For knowledgeable conversation regarding gutters see the article : Everything You Need to Know About Your Gutters – In Layman’s Terms.

3. Don’t give into high-pressure sales. If a company feels the need to pressure, this is the first sign of poor customer service and likely a poor product. If they don’t respect you when you’re deciding to buy, likely they won’t respect you when you have a problem after purchase.

things to look for when considering gutter guards in Kansas city

This Expert’s Opinion

Choose a completely solid gutter guard from a well-established reputable company. Make sure they have a history of backing their warranty, trained installers and a history of excellent customer service. 

Gutter Cover Kansas City® offers the best gutter protection system in Kansas City. They tick all the boxes. There are no perforations or openings in the top, it has a nose forward design to block debris, it maximizes surface tension, is backed by a reputable company, installed by professionals, comes highly recommended, no plastic parts, and it offers and honors a lifetime guarantee that the gutters will never clog. What else could you want from a gutter protection company?


Updated from original posting 10/30/2020